Both machines make the same soft, chewable nugget ice on a countertop with no plumbing. They split on two things: how much ice each is rated to make, and how much of it you control from a phone.
The comparison below uses the manufacturers' published specifications only. No prices, ratings or availability are quoted.
The two products compared
Product details come from our central product records. Prices change constantly, so check the retailer for the current price.
Affiliate disclosure — As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. TopPremiumPicks may also earn commissions from other retailers. This costs you nothing extra and does not influence our recommendations.
Product A
GE Profile
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker
Premium ($$$$)
Best for: soft-water homes that want the proven Opal at the lower price
The machine that made chewable nugget ice a countertop category. GE specifies production of up to 38 lb of nugget ice per 24 hours from a 0.75-gallon reservoir, with app control, scheduling and a side-tank accessory port for longer unattended runs.
Product B
Frigidaire
Frigidaire EFIC237 Nugget Ice Maker, 44 lb
Upper Mid-Range ($$$)
Best for: households that want the most chewable ice per day from a familiar brand
A brand-name nugget machine rated at 44 lb per 24 hours in a black stainless countertop body. Frigidaire specifies a first batch of soft, chewable ice within roughly 15 minutes and an automatic self-cleaning cycle, which makes it the high-output alternative to the Opal for buyers who want a familiar appliance name without app scheduling.
Comparison at a glance
| Category | GE Profile Opal 2.0 | Frigidaire EFIC237 | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ice type | Nugget (chewable) | Nugget (chewable) | Tie |
| Rated output | Up to 38 lb per 24 hours | Up to 44 lb per 24 hours | Frigidaire |
| First ice | Longer nugget cycle | About 15 minutes | Frigidaire |
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi with SmartHQ app | Panel controls (no app) | Opal 2.0 |
| Expansion | 0.75 gallon, side-tank compatible | Onboard reservoir | Opal 2.0 |
| Check price | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
What is identical
The ice. Both compress flake ice into the soft, chewable nuggets people buy this category for, and neither needs plumbing — you fill a reservoir and empty a basket.
Both are full-size machines with an auger, so both need counter depth, under-cabinet height and tolerance for a steady mechanical hum.
Output against control
Frigidaire rates the EFIC237 at up to 44 lb per 24 hours against the Opal's 38 lb, with a first batch in roughly 15 minutes. In a busy kitchen that is faster recovery after every rush.
The Opal answers with SmartHQ scheduling, status and cleaning reminders, plus the accessory side tank for long unattended runs. Neither of those exists on the Frigidaire.
Long-term ownership
The Opal line has years of filters, side tanks and service behind it, which matters for an appliance with an auger and a compressor inside.
Neither machine has scale-focused filtration, so in hard-water homes filtered water and a disciplined cleaning cycle decide how long either one keeps its output.
Keep reading
Frequently asked questions
Final verdict
Want the most chewable ice per day with no app to set up: the Frigidaire EFIC237. Want scheduling, reminders and the side tank that lets the machine run unattended: the Opal 2.0. The ice itself is not the deciding factor — it is the same on both.
Best for soft-water homes that want the proven Opal at the lower price
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker
The most established nugget platform on the market, with the widest accessory and support ecosystem.
Best for households that want the most chewable ice per day from a familiar brand
Frigidaire EFIC237 Nugget Ice Maker, 44 lb
Top-of-pool rated nugget output from a long-established appliance brand.
About Our Research
TopPremiumPicks researches and compares products using manufacturer information, published specifications, reputable sources, retailer information and documented customer feedback.
How We Review Products